I’m doing it again! At the moment we’re counting down an entire new set of cookies on the lookout for a new winner of the Best Bakery Cookies to Order Online Showdown!! Last yr’s cookies have been REALLY robust to beat, so take a look at the 2018 winner of Best Online Cookies. However right here we’re in 2019 doing it all once more with an entire new set of contenders!
The BEST Bakery Cookies To Order Online!
YOU GUYS! That is easily probably the most anticipated submit of the yr here on Cookies and Cups! Last yr I ordered and tried TONS of cookies online, and had an epic time doing it. And I still assume last yr’s prime 3 bakeries final yr are fairly exhausting to beat. But I decided to attempt it again with an entire new batch of bakeries. And you recognize what I discovered? This yr’s prime 3 are ALSO fairly incredible!
Like last yr, I needed to comply with alongside the same set of parameters. I LOVE visiting bakeries once I journey, and am in a position to attempt so many fun candy treats wherever I’m going, so I assumed it might be fun to see how many of those bakeries across the country SHIP their treats, so everyone can attempt the cookies I speak about over on Instagram. Final yr I selected some bakeries I had already tried once I visited them, but hadn’t ever ordered online, so it was great to give you the option to examine their shipped model vs their “fresh” version. Last yr’s winner ended up being a bakery I had never visited in individual, however subsequent time I’m in Chicago I’m DEFINITELY popping in.
This Yr Is a Entire Set of Bakeries That Are New To Me!
Like final yr, I tried to principally remove massive chain corporations. I attempt to hold it small, local bakeries that ship their treats…with one (I feel) exception. AND this yr I took each single Bakery suggestion from you guys over on Instagram, which I feel it SUPER enjoyable! I had a couple of late entries are available with people who needed to get in on the showdown, which is all the time enjoyable that you simply guys get as excited about cookies as I do!!
I might be sharing the Prime 10 that I ordered this yr. I had greater than 10 entries, but I truthfully didn’t love lots of the cookies I acquired this yr, so as an alternative of talking about what I didn’t like, I’ll give attention to these I did and why! The #1 cookie this yr is SUPER enjoyable, completely totally different, and would significantly be one of the best present to obtain within the mail, or heck, only a fun deal with to present yourself!
How Did I Fee The Bakeries?
So there were a couple of key factors I needed to hit on once I ranked these bakeries. Additionally know that this is utterly my opinion solely, and my purpose is to aid you guys as readers and giving my trustworthy opinion without being destructive. Also notice that I only picked a number of kinds of cookies from each bakery (all the time truing to order the chocolate chip cookie) so I definitely wasn’t in a position to pattern all the things every bakery has to supply. But here have been the main points I used in my ranking:
- Style/Freshness (obviously). This is an important issue in the rating. It gained’t matter how pretty a cookie is packaged or extravagant the elements if it doesn’t TASTE good!
- Packaging/Presentation. While this isn’t as essential as taste, I feel prefer it’s an enormous issue when ordering cookies online. I might guess that over half the time cookies are ordered online it’s as a present, and the best way the cookies are packaged and introduced is part of the enjoyable. A number of of the cookies I ordered have been left off the listing utterly due to poor packaging. Plus, in the event that they aren’t packaged rigorously, they will come damaged, which is one other big cookie fail.
- Velocity of Delivery. I consider this also elements into the freshness, so if the cookies take every week to get to me after being ordered, they are obviously at LEAST every week previous.
- Worth. Positive, ordering cookies online isn’t the most cost effective means to get your cookie repair, so definitely there is a premium to be paid for this. But when the cookies are overly priced, or if delivery costs more than the cookies (yep, that’s a factor), that may be a large flip off.
So let’s get began, we could?
7343 Kingston Pike Knoxville, TN 37919
Worth: $25.99 for a dozen
Delivery: $12.50. Arrived 2 days after order was positioned.
Ok, I’ll say that my least favorite a part of my On-line Bakery Showdown is having to let you understand which cookies I wouldn’t advocate. Unfortunately if I’ve 10 slots, and somebody has to are available final. While cookies from Moonshine have been tender and recent, they have been all damaged. I enjoyed their taste, and thought their “Berry White” and “Sugar Shine” have been standouts, tasting like something you baked proper in your personal kitchen. BUT they fell apart and have been all broken. Such a bummer.
2854 18th Road South Homewood, AL, 35209
Worth: $33.88 for a tin of a dozen
Delivery: $30.20. Arrived 4 days after order was placed
Ok, so once I’m spending over $60 on cookies I anticipate to be wowed. Wanting at the cookie choices on their website acquired me instantly excited, however unfortunately not one of the superb flavors appear to be obtainable to ship, only for native delivery. I completely get that, especially for small outlets. What they do ship are tins crammed with a dozen cookies. Sadly you’ll be able to’t alter the flavors in the tins. So when you order a dozen in a tin you possibly can only get one taste per tin. The pictures on the web page are deceptive, wanting like each tin comes with quite a lot of flavors, but if you learn the outline, every tin is only one taste.
I ordered one tin with a dozen chocolate chip cookies. The tin was cute, but again, about half the cookies got here damaged inside. The bottom of the tin was a layer of cookie crumbs from the broken cookies, with the cookies on prime being principally intact. The cookies themselves have been okay, however when delivery prices over $30 you’d hope they wouldn’t all be broken. I utterly perceive that when the cookies are out of the bakery’s arms and into the palms of the shippers there isn’t much you can do, BUT I know I have ordered numerous cookies for these posts and a lot of the cookies are available good situation, so I know it’s potential.
18279 Brookhurst St. Suite 1 Fountain Valley, CA 92708
Worth: $18.95 for 4
Delivery: $20.75. Arrived 7 days after order was placed
This was a late addition to the showdown, they usually have been good! I ordered 4 cookies, and they are pretty big. They’ve a limited choice of flavors for delivery, so I selected the Assortment Box which included a Chocolate Chip, Darkish Chocolate Peanut Butter, Triple Chocolate, and Blueberry Coconut Pecan. The website says you possibly can alter the flavors in the assortment by just leaving a remark when ordering, so I appreciated that choice. The purpose they came in eighth on the listing is that delivery was more than the cookies, they usually additionally came 7 days after the order was placed, which was longer than most. I’ll observe they are in California and I am in New Jersey, in order that they did have to travel across the nation, however I other comes from CA they usually arrived a lot quicker.
Additionally I’ll word that I attempted these cookies both straight out of the box, and in addition heated up in the microwave for a couple of seconds, and I solely favored them warm. In fact most cookies are better warm, I get it, but I found these have been actually ONLY good heat. I am going to assume that’s mainly because they weren’t fairly as recent due to the lengthy delivery time.
1205 third Ave N Nashville, TN 37208
2606 12th Ave S. Nashville, TN 37204
Worth: $14.95 for a tin of 6
Delivery: $eight.00. Arrived three days after order was positioned.
Okay, have you ever ever stayed at a DoubleTree Lodge? Upon check-in they provide you a warm Chocolate Chip cookie. It’s pretty superb. So when a reader beneficial that I attempt Christie’s Cookies in Tennessee I virtually passed as a result of it gave me more of a “Corporate Gift” vibe than selfmade cookie vibe. Until I saw that they are the bakery liable for the famous DoubleTree cookie!
I decided to order a tin and just see in the event that they have been nearly as good as I keep in mind, and oh sure they are. They came in a tin with 6, they usually have been smooth, recent, and equally nearly as good warm or at room temperature. The delivery was completely affordable, and came in three days.
The solely cause I didn’t rank this one greater, is beyond the DoubleTree Cookie, I felt like every thing else was just a little commonplace. BUT I might completely advocate these.
Examine web site for native markets in Texas
Worth: $32 for a field of 6
Delivery: $zero. Arrived 7 days after order was placed
I was really liked The Cookie Society and only wished I had ordered more flavors! I ended up ordering a a “Bakery 6 Pack” which solely permits you to choose 2 flavors, so I picked Birthday Cake and Chocolate Chip. Both have been good, however we favored the Birthday Cake taste the most effective, which was a tender sugar cookie loaded with sprinkles.
The cookies have been on the thinner aspect, however have been both gentle and recent. They have some actually enjoyable flavors and would absolutely order from The Cookie Society again!
A number of places in Utah
Worth: $10 for a box of four
Delivery: $16.03. Arrived 7 days after order was placed
Okay, just take a look at that chocolate chip cookie. That’s MY type of cookie. We actually beloved the cookies we received from Chip and I guess when you’ve got an area Chip close to you they’re phenomenal. We also ordered the seasonal choice which was primarily a chocolate chip cookie but with Cadbury Eggs and white chips. It was good, however we favored the Chocolate Chip higher.
I’ll say their website was just a little glitchy, and their taste selection was limited for delivery. Additionally they took 7 days to get to me, with delivery costing more than the cookies, but they have been packaged nicely, got here intact, and have been simply nearly as good straight out of the field as they have been heated up!
Sweet Treats Truck Cease in San Diego
Worth: $32 for 6 cookies
Delivery: $15. Arrived three days after being shipped.
Okay, these cookies are tremendous artistic and actually enjoyable. The owner reached out to me on Instagram and I informed her to shock me with what flavors she sent. You’ll be able to order these by way of Instagram, or for those who’re in San Diego on the Sweet Treats Truck. I acquired The Blueberry Pie Stuffed Lemon Cream, the Carnival Cookie which is a sugar cookies full of a White Fudge Ding Dong, Strawberry Goals which is Strawberry Cheesecake Dough full of a Strawberry Twinkie, and MOnkey’s Paradise which is banana dough with coconut, peanut butter chips and full of caramel.
We really appreciated these, and warmed up they have been great. Hopefully they’ll provide you with a neater means to order as their business grows, as a result of as of right now you message the proprietor on Instagram.
2 places in NYC
Worth: $5.50 every (I ordered 6)
Delivery: $eight. Arrived in the future after order was positioned.
And identical to last yr, things now get somewhat murky. What I mean is any of these prime three cookie choices might be #1 depending on my temper! You aren’t going to go flawed getting any of these, but I undoubtedly feel like all of them might attraction to what you’re craving!
Duchess Cookies have been the first cookies to arrive at the house after all of the orders have been places, solely taking 1 day to arrive. I will say that I’m in NJ and these come from NY, in order that they didn’t have far to journey. We LOVED the enjoyable flavors and in case you comply with them on Instagram you will notice all the videos of people breaking these beauties in half. They’re undoubtedly a showstopper.
I LOVED LOVED the Unicorn Cookie which was full of a sprinkle cheesecake filling, however my boys liked the Cookie Monster Cookie and the chocolate chip.
I’ll say these ought to undoubtedly be heated up to get the complete effect, but I HIGHLY advocate getting these in the event you’re on the lookout for an excellent dun cookie!
Multiple places across the country
Worth: $10 for a field of four
Delivery: $19.14. Arrived 5 days after order was positioned.
So Crumbl was THE MOST advisable cookie from you guys. I acquired a whole lot of votes for Crumbl once I requested for bakery concepts over on Instagram, and now I know why. Towards my general annoyance when delivery costs more than the cookies themselves, there isn’t any denying that Crumbl Cookies are WORTH IT. I hate that the image above doesn’t really capture how good these are. I solely acquired a four pack, 2 Sugar Cookies and a couple of Chocolate Chip cookies, but their Chocolate Chip Cookies have been my favourite of the yr (with the one contender for CCC being from Chip). SO SO GOOD!
I wish I had ordered the Social gathering Field, which accommodates 12 large cookies. The Sugar Cookies come with the frosting separate, which is good, and are supposed to be chilled. I attempted them not chilled and then chilled, and they are right, chilling the sugar cookies is the best way to go!
The chocolate chip cookies are SO tender and yummy, and my solely remorse is I didn’t order more. UGH.
69 Wesley Road South Hackensack, NJ 07606
Additionally bought at Dylan’s Candy Bar NYC
Worth: $25 for a box of 4
Delivery: $18. Arrived 2 days after order was positioned
Okay, right here we’re at the prime spot. But like I stated at the start, any of the highest three bakeries are winners, all for various causes. It was REALLY onerous to decide the #1 this yr as a result of if I used to be just craving a chocolate chip cookie, Crumbl can be the winner. BUT in case you are in search of a true, distinctive cookie EXPERIENCE Dana’s is the winner.
The cause Dana’s gained is their “Mookie” which is a large cookie full of a Macaron! These have been SO enjoyable!! We liked the Funfetti Taste probably the most, but the Oatmeal Rain stuffed wit a raspberry jam macaron was so so good too. I imply all their flavor combos have been nice! For those who heat them up they get SUPER gooey and scrumptious.
The Cookie Lover Combo is the best way to go, with some of their super fun Rainbow Black and White Cookies and 5 “Mookies”.
Dana’s HQ is in New Jersey, so I was so excited to study that they have been local to me, though I’ll say that I had no concept they have been in NJ until after I had positioned the order.
Dana’s seems to be most recognized for the superb French Macarons, that are also superb present options. However pricey buddies, the Mookie is an EXPERIENCE and I highly advocate, which is why I’m choosing Dana’s as #1 this yr!!
Are You Craving a Cookie But?
Once more, this submit is completely unsponsored, based mostly soley on my opinions, and not meant to be something however informative. And like I stated before, every bakery on this listing was a suggestion from YOU GUYS! It’s also protected to say that every bakery on this listing is someone’s favorite, so do your greatest to verify all of them out and make your personal selections. I’d LOVE to know should you agree with me!